The challenge of climate change
Posted on Apr 3rd, 2008
by
Malcolm
Yes, friends, I’m still alive!
Life has been full of challenge and change in the last month, but I’m slowly coming down to earth, and almost ready to start blogging again. My last entry was when Christine and I were packing up our house a few days before leaving home for 6 months. Since then we’ve spent 10 days in Thailand, and almost 3 weeks settling into life in Perth, Western Australia. We’ve been giving and preparing workshops and lectures, and catching up with friends and family, as well as fending off the ‘flu and trying to get enough sleep. Today I’ll give few impressions of our journey so far.
In Thailand, we stayed at Wongsanit Ashram, headquarters of the Spirit in Education Movement which is engaged with issues of sustainability and social change. Their diverse programmes include Ecovillage Design Education, teaching Laotion Buddhist monks about the modern world and Thai youth about the importance of Buddhist values, helping remote hill tribes to plan for their future, and assisting Burmese refugees displaced by the Tsunami.
Wongsanit Ashram
Situated 1.5 hours from central Bangkok, the ashram is an oasis of peace in a seething hive of 12m people. We’d never been to one of the mega-cities of the majority world before, and it was quite an eye-opener on the trips we took out of the Ashram. First impressions on leaving the vast new international airport terminal are of endless freeways and spaghetti junctions. In places, the subsiding switchback of old road is overshadowed by the elevated tollway for the rich, and paralleled by the rotting concrete of unfinished schemes – monuments to past corruption.
At major junctions, nestled amongst the grey strands of spaghetti, are huge shopping malls, such as Future Park which has just announced plans to create a patch of ‘rainforest’ for the delight of its customers. Never before have I seen a supermarket with 53 checkouts, and this looked small compared to the Tesco Lotus across the road – yes, that archetypal British model of an aggressive multinational seems set to add dominance of Thai retailing to its crown.
Consumerism is not only alive and well in Bangkok, it’s booming. I haven’t been in the USA recently, but I suspect it’s lost the title of king of the giant billboards. Everywhere you look, the landscape is dominated by the brash drive to sell and the urgent desire to buy. And yet amongst the smaller shops and stalls, the sellers are not importunate. They watch and wait patiently, and only come forward to encourage those who seem interested.
Bangkok billboard
The meteoric rise of consumerism is epitomised by the vehicles that clog the roads. Apart from a remnant of tuk-tuks and pedicabs, everyone seems either to ride a jazzily-styled scooter, or to drive a shiny big Toyota. Noticeable by their absence are old cars and the mini models so popular in European cities.
This blatant exhibition of new-found wealth sits side by side with inequalities far larger than those in the west. Shacks surrounded by garbage sit side by side with nouveau-riche mansions. Pavement sellers spread their pitiful wares outside glitzy shops, as blind beggars shuffle through the crowds. And pedicab riders move painfully amongst the teeming cars.
Inevitably, we found ourselves wondering how Bangkok will tackle climate change. How can their trajectory to the pinnacle of consumerism be diverted towards sustainability? How can we possibly expect the poor to forego their vision of a better life until they have a modern apartment with an airconditioner, and a Toyota parked outside? How can the flood of gleaming metal pouring down the concrete rivers possibly be diverted? The only sign of hope we saw in our brief stay was the announcement by the government that it plans to complete its multi-billion dollar mass transit network within the next three years – a target few seem to think is feasible. Even the ashram with its simple traditional lifestyle has its challenges. Every time their activities take them into the city, there is over an hour of driving each way.
Cut to Perth, Western Australia. Now one of the wealthiest cities in the world, riding the resources boom created by Chinese and Indian economic growth. A city with the highest rate of car ownership in the world, and more miles of road per person than even Los Angeles. A city whose food is mostly trucked thousands of miles across the continent. A city whose houses require airconditioning in summer and heating in winter despite a climate in which neither should be necessary. A city which, despite water shortages, still emulates the verdant British countryside.
Perth across the River Swan
The resources boom is a mixed blessing. Perth, and indeed the whole south-west of the State, has become ‘home’ to highly-paid fly-in, fly-out mine workers who work hard and live hard. As a result, property prices have gone through the roof, and there is a parallel boom in homelessness. Mental illness and suicide rates are high, as are drug addiction, crime and anti-social behaviour. When we arrived, the media were discussing new penalties for the ‘one punch’ murders that have become common in brawls.
Perth has the dubious distinction of being capital of the state with the highest per capita greenhouse gas emissions in the world. And Western Australia also has the dubious distinction of being a region that will suffer more than most from the impacts of climate change. Fresh water will become even scarcer. Much of its farming land will become desert. Its rich heritage as a biodiversity hot spot will be lost. Perth’s famed beaches will disappear. More people will die from the heat. …
Once again, the question arises: how on earth can such a city become environmentally sustainable? How can it possibly reduce its emissions of carbon within 20 or 30 years from 34 tonnes per capita per annum to the 2 tonnes that Gaia can absorb on average? (That’s a 94% reduction!) And yet climate change seems to be way down the political agenda here. How can ‘sandgropers’, as Western Australians are often called, be diverted from their complaisant hedonism to take their danger seriously?
University of WA
A theme running through the course is the perception that our consumerist behaviour is a form of addiction. Each week we’re introducing a few steps from “twelve steps to a spiritual ecology” adapted from the Alcoholics Anonymous programme. The first vital step is to recognise that we are indeed addicted to ‘stuff’: “We admit that we are addicted and living in a society that fosters this addiction, and that we are powerless over our addiction to stop it.” (If you haven't already seen "The Story of Stuff", it's well worth the 20 minutes!) Steps 2 and 3 are to accept that we are parts of a much larger and mysterious whole, and that we can tap the healing power of this whole by surrendering our lives and wills to it.
Christine and I find one of our biggest challenges is how to engage with our own families and friends. It’s relatively easy to stand up in a room of strangers and talk about ways in which they could change. But we find it much harder to discuss specifics with our adult children. They are aware and concerned about the issues, but, like all of us, are inconsistent in their responses. How can we lovingly, uncritically, without judgement, without sparking anger or resentment, point out that driving long distances for minor reasons is no longer appropriate; that over-filling the electric jug wastes energy; that collecting trivial consumer items is not ok; that taking the time to read labels and minimise ‘food miles’ is worthwhile; or that living in the country is no longer sustainable? And how can we truly justify our own ‘love miles’ to be with them? Should we give up seeing our families, scattered as they are across the globe, for the good of the planet?
As climate change bites harder, we will all be faced by these and many similar dilemmas.
Tagged with: Thailand, Bangkok, Perth, Western Australia, climate change, greenhouse gas, carbon dioxide, emissions, policy, action, addiction, stuff, community, education, love miles

Help




Malcolm, Thank you so much for this thoughtful post. As you address these challenges, please share your difficulties and successes here. We are thirsty for understanding. I face the same challenges with my family and friends and co-workers, in varying degrees. Have you seen www.earthhour.org – If Sydney can do it, maybe Perth can too. It could be a start toward helping people wake up to their energy usage.
San Francisco seems to be pretty cutting edge in terms of cities caring for the environment. I know it can help to look to cities that are already successfully implementing change. heres' another one…. www.toronto.zerofootprint.net
We have been wondering how to get an earth hour event organized world wide at least once a month instead of once a year… http://victoria-is.gaia.com/blog/2008/3/earth_hour_2008
Here's some good news happening in Portland, Oregon…. http://www.theflyinghammer.com/bak/
I'll post any more good news as comments here as I find them. and I'll be eagerly looking here for more news from Perth. Thanks again SO much for this post. Your work is inspiring.
As an aside I'm just been reading this book…. Healing the Addictive Mind by Lee Jampolsky – It starts out right away by defining an addiction as anything outside of ourselves that we look to for happiness. I think it might tie in to your work. Here is Dr Jampolsky's website with a list of links that are fantastic. Maybe climate change is an opportunity and maybe it will take a miracle – there's a link on that website to the A Course in Miracles Website. I'm exploring now.
With much love and encouragement,
-Dawn (in Colorado)
and oh yes– I think the best way to convince our loved ones to change is to show them through our actions how much their standard of living can be joyfully increased and deepened through buying local and organic and even planting our own gardens, but having less stuff– because stuff takes up so much of our time getting it and then taking care of it. live a magical, joyfully existence with LESS stuff and using LESS resources and then you are a shining example for all.
Asking difficult questions of our loved ones is the LOVING thing to do and if we do it in a non confrontational, non judgemental way with the idea that they may actually be doing more than we know to help the planet, it doesn't have to be ugly. And when one challenges us to walk our own talk– we should thank them and we should take those challenges as opportunities to improve…..
as far as those love miles go— ???? I have no advice to offer. Perhaps seriously go out and plant enough trees to offset the emissions or even to offset them twice over? If we can afford the plane tickets, can we not also afford the expense of planting the trees. Perhaps even plant the trees together as a joyful family activity when you are all together and as a thank you to the planet for providing the resources to the companies that make aeroplanes and the companies that provide fuel for the airplanes and etc. when you are together– rather than driving around to various activities and going out to eat, you could cook wonderful meal for the family and by example show how lovely local, organic, mostly veggie food can be?
or, & I bet this would be the one of the more effective strategies…. share those very questions you pose with them, ask them what they think the answers are, as if you think they will really have some answers for you, as if you can REALLY learn from THEM. You might be surprised what they come up with. As them for their help in inspiring the work you are doing in Perth. Who better to ask for insights about people than other regular people?
here's the four fold path to truce, as I have learned it….
1) show up
2) pay attention
3) tell the truth (your own truth will have to do, no? at least since we have all different ideas about THE truth)
4) be unattached to outcome
being unattached to outcome can be the hardest part here– especially when it comes to the environment.
I used to think it meant not caring, but what I've come to understand is that it means accepting that the outcome may not be what I prefer it to be and finding my peace in that acceptance. I don't know how to put that better. It helps me to think that my way though it seems right to me and that I feel I have learned lessons and found what I think is a BETTER way, I may be wrong. The outcome that I least prefer, may be the “better” way in the long through a series of events that I cannot now see from my limited perspective.
here is the quote that I have taped to my locker at work that helps me to remember and understand day by day…..
“what the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the master calls a butterfly”.
:-)
-dawn
Malcolm, I enjoyed your post very much and were delighted to be pointed towards Annie Leonard's page. Wouldn't it be great of her video found its way into our schools? I will certainly pass it on to all the teachers I know.
There is much to think about here.
P.S. I loved Dawn's quote about the caterpillar!
Thanks Dawn and Mamakat for the feedback, thoughts, love and encouragement. I'll certainly keep blogging.
Blessings
Malcolm